More HB: How To Catch A Pop Up 101
June 13, 2009 in More HB, NY Mets, NY Yankees

Luis Castillo drops a routine A-Rod pop up in another excruciating Met loss to their crosstown rivals in the Bronx.
Sometimes, baseball’s a funny game. You just never know when you’re going to get the bounces/breaks. As someone who’s covered the Low-A Staten Island Yankees four summers, I know all about that borrowing that quote from a former player who used it quite a bit.
I’ve seen my share of wild endings where the Baby Bombers came out on top. I can recall one huge walkoff win over the bitter Verrazano rival Cyclones a couple of years prior in which it was the wild pitch that scored the winning run was very predictable, concluding a topsy turvy game filled with mistakes. Sometimes, baseball can be a sloppy game. It’s to be expected when you cover most kids only out of college who were just drafted and still adjusting to their first summer of pro ball.
Errors are part of the game and it even can happen to guys at the highest level as was the case during last night’s unreal finish in the Bronx where Luis Castillo botched a routine A-Rod pop up- muffing it allowing both Derek Jeter and a hustling Mark Teixeira to come in and score the tying and winning runs in a stunning 9-8 win over the Mets.
You just can’t make it up. There I was watching the wild conclusion following a great Game 7 that saw the Pens shock the Red Wings winning Lord Stanley 2-1. As the celebration ended, we flipped to SNY to watch Francisco Rodriguez try to close out the Yankees. The new Met closer entered perfect in 16 save chances. And here he was one out away from save No.17 with Jeter in scoring position and Teixeira, who earlier took Livan Hernandez deep for his AL leading 20th was on first with K-Rod opting to give an intentional pass and take his chances versus the Lightning Rod.
It was a night before that Alex Rodriguez delivered a big two out two-run double giving the Yanks a 3-1 lead on the Red Sox only to see teflon skipper Joe Girardi stay with C.C. Sabathia too long before not going to Mariano Rivera as Boston plated three in the eighth to make it eight for eight in 2009 (nine in a row dating to last year). This time, here was the big third base slugger in another huge spot looking to deliver in the clutch. And he was being pitched to over Teixeira due in large part to K-Rod’s history against him. Surely, one of the game’s best players would make the cocky Met closer pay. When he missed with three straight, the deck was stacked in Alex’s favor. After taking a 95 MPH heater down the middle, he had the green light on 3-1. Here it came. A perfect fastball that had “hit me” on it yet all he could manage was one of those dreadful uppercut swings producing a weak pop to second.
The game was over, right? A-Rod felt so slamming down his bat in frustration while jogging to first probably pondering how he didn’t crush it. But a funny thing happened. Here was Castillo calling everyone off backing up to short right. That’s when I noticed how messed up his footing was with the ball traveling further left than the Met second baseman anticipated. It was at that moment that I actually wondered, ‘Is he really gonna drop it?’ in not believing fashion.
You never figure a routine pop could somehow elude a major league player. Especially one the caliber of Castillo, who once was an All-Star who helped the Marlins win the 2003 World Series. Especially an experienced guy who once won three consecutive Gold Gloves. So, he’s certainly capable defensively. Maybe at 33, Castillo isn’t quite as sure handed and has lost some range which happens to middle infielders as they get older. Entering last night, he had five errors- one fewer than all of last year in half a season and all of two of those three Gold Glove seasons in Florida.
Still, even the biggest Yankee homer had to figure the game was over with Girardi once again the goat for bringing in his aging closer in a tie game only to see him see his shadow with David Wright driving one to the right center gap for the go-ahead run. Instead, here was Castillo struggling with his footing as the ball came down. And then it happened. No. Not George Foreman stunning Michael Moorer with a big right to once again claim the heavyweight title as HBO’s Jim Lampley excitedly called last decade.
Listening to Gary Cohen describe the action was something else. When A-Rod popped it up, the SNY play-by-play man got excited anticipating the end of the game and what would’ve been a good win in which the Amazin’s showed grit coming back three separate times. And why not? Especially after two bitter extra inning defeats to the Phillies and this was at the new evil Yankee Palace. A chance to get back on track and gain a game with Philly losing in 13 to Boston. But instead of calling that final out for K-Rod’s 17th save, he couldn’t fathom what happened next.
There was Castillo backing up and the ball bouncing off the heel of his glove. Stunned disbelief as Jeter scored and Teixeira came around from first sliding in with Alex Cora’s relay too late. Why did he have the ball? Because Castillo panicked tossing into second. We’ll never know why. Was it the moment? Who knows. Just like that, the Mets had invented a new way to lose.
What followed from a Yankee standpoint was pandemonium as they mobbed A-Rod like he was some hero for his weak pop that 999 out of 1,000 times would’ve ended the game. Afterwards, he called it a huge break referring to it as “a gift from God and Castillo.” You don’t say.
For Castillo, who was the whipping boy last year, he came under huge fire from angry Met fans who now want him banished. Only thing is the Mets don’t exactly have a replacement. And last we checked, he has bounced back entering today at .277 with 14 RBI’s, seven steals and a solid .376 on-base percentage (29 walks). Good on Jerry Manuel running him back out there for today’s game which his team is currently leading 5-1 halfway thru.
Can they hang on with no-name call-up Fernando Nieve’s only mistake a solo shot to A-Rod? Hopefully for Castillo’s sake, that’s the case. After all, this is baseball. Where you get to comeback after a brutal loss the next day and try to win and forget the previous night. If the Mets show character and take these next two with ace Johan Santana going tomorrow and go on a run, will anyone remember Friday night? For now, the lingering thoughts will remain until we get to September when the games take on a whole new meaning.
So, Castillo will hear the boos when the Mets return to Citi Field next Friday. But hey. He didn’t duck the postgame interview and there weren’t any excuses. It’s baseball and sometimes, these things happen. So, the radio experts will continue to kill him for only using one hand to make the catch. But how many ballplayers use two on routine pops? And it starts at a young age.
We can always second guess from our armchairs but are we playing a kid’s game having made it as far as Mr. Castillo has? Hell no. Of course, it doesn’t keep us from ripping into him for not squeezing it. At least Jeter understood that these things can happen. He is human and last we checked, we all are bullet proof. Unfortunately in this town, you’re remembered for what you just did. It can change though. Maybe it does a month from now with the Mets still chasing the Phils.
That’s what makes baseball so unpredictable. A funny game indeed.












