
With Game 4 about to begin, only a couple of changes to each lineup tonight in the Bronx.
The Yankees are starting Doug Mientkiewicz at first over Jason Giambi and the Indians are giving a start to catcher Kelly Shoppach while shifting Victor Martinez to first which means Ryan Garko is on the bench.

And already, the Indians are off to a quick start as Grady Sizemore leads off with a home run to right center off Chien-Ming Wang stunning the Stadium crowd.
Not the kind of beginning Joe Torre would like to see from his No.1 starter going on three days rest. If he runs into more trouble, expect Mike Mussina to be ready in what’s another do-or-die postseason game.
Already Wang has left two pitches up for two hits while retiring Asdrubal Cabrera on a grounder to first. His stuff must be down in order to be successful.
With Travis Hafner in scoring position with two out and Jhonny Peralta at the plate, TBS flashes an appropriate graphic in this series which has the Indians scoring 13 times with RISP as opposed to just one for the Yanks.
Peralta had a couple of hits last night and has had a good series. Wang goes full on him missing the outside corner with pest Kenny Lofton on deck. The Cleveland shortstop bloops one just over Robinson Cano’s head as the Indians once again take advantage for a big two out hit to put them on top 2-0.
You have to wonder if the Yanks can overcome another bad start such as this one. It’s obvious Eric Wedge’s club means business and wants to get this over with tonight.
Wang finally gets out of it by getting Lofton to bounce back to him.
Now his teammates will try to pick him up against Cleveland starter Paul Byrd, who won 15 games.
Yesterday, the Indians got a run in each of the first three before the Yanks stormed back with seven of their eight in the middle innings.
As Byrd gets Johnny Damon on a grounder to Peralta, TBS flashes a stat that he had the best record (9-3) after losses this year. So it won’t be easy for New York.
Derek Jeter who needs to get going takes Byrd’s first offering the other way for his second hit of the series. Bobby Abreu follows by getting enough of a tough inside pitch to punch it into right for the Yanks’ first rally bringing up Alex Rodriguez with runners on first and second one out.
It’s very important for the Yanks to respond here as A-Rod just misses a pitch down the middle to fall behind 0-2. Byrd gets him to chase through a high fastball for the second out. Only a few boos but mostly murmurs from a nervous home crowd as Jorge Posada comes up.
Posada fists one to short left but a hustling Lofton makes a sliding catch to prevent a run ending the threat.
Another frustrating inning in which the Yanks couldn’t get a runner home in scoring position with two out. The Indians have had good success (11-for-23) while the Bronx Bombers have bombed out. They’re now 0-for-7. That right there is the difference so far.
The Yanks will need Wang to be sharper. After Franklin Gutierrez leads off the second with a single, it’s apparent that he’s getting too many pitches up which could be a bad sign for the home team.
Casey Blake puts another hittable pitch into left and a few boos can be heard. Wang clearly doesn’t have it and must be replaced before the game is broken open. Already, Mussina is seen getting ready.
Now, the confused umpires can’t figure out if a Wang high sinker hit Shoppach who was trying to square. It looked like a bad call. Regardless, the bases are now loaded with nobody out with Wang in a world of trouble.
The TBS replays seem to indicate that it did get part of the hand and bat which wasn’t back. So wouldn’t that be a strike? In any event, big trouble here for the Yanks with Sizemore who already jacked one out up looking to inflict more damage.
Joe Torre already pulls Wang and it reminds us way too much about that awful conclusion to a historic collapse back in Game 7 of the ALCS against Boston three years ago. It was a dreadful Kevin Brown who the manager pulled in favor of Javier Vazquez, whose first pitch was deposited into the right field seats by then Red Sock Damon.
Ironically, Sizemore like Damon is the Indians’ leadoff center fielder. Can anyone say yikes as Moose warms up?
Mussina falls behind 2-1 but is able to induce a 4-6-3 double play allowing just one Indian to cross home plate as the Yanks fall behind three runs.
If he can get Cabrera here, this could have a whole different feel. The young Cleveland second baseman fouls off a couple of pitches and then takes a high curve into center for another big two out RBI for the Indians who now are up four. They’re now 12-for-24 in the series.
It’s hard to see the Yanks winning this. They’ll basically need Mussina to silence the Cleveland bats the rest of the way because their strong pen which includes Rafael Perez and Betancourt are rested.
You couldn’t draw up a more shocking start to this game. One which many including ourself felt the Yanks would win to force a deciding fifth game back at Jacobs Field Wednesday.
Mussina loses Travis Hafner to put runners on first and second with the dangerous Martinez up.
Chip Caray makes a valid point about how the Yankee pitchers haven’t been able to finish off Cleveland batters with two strikes. Can Moose get Martinez here?
Fans start a “Let’s Go Yankees” chant to encourage their team. It works as Mussina finally gets Martinez to ground out to Cano which ends another painful inning.
Final line on Wang who was knocked around this series:
1 IP, 4 ER, 5 H, 32 pitches (20 strikes)
He’s definitely taken a hit here. How will the third-year pitcher comeback from this?
Now the plate ump somehow misses catcher’s interference from Shoppach on a Hideki Matsui foul ball. The DH hit the Indians’ glove. How is it possible to miss that when it’s right in front of you?
Now Byrd is protesting that Matsui stepped out while he was winding up. This umpire stinks. Fieldin Culbreth needs some med. Yes. That’s really his first name.
The count runs full and Matsui draws a leadoff walk and justifiably is on first. Funny how this game of baseball works out sometimes.
It’s only the third time Byrd has walked a leadoff hitter this year which speaks to how well he pitches.
One of Game Three’s heroes Cano steps in and gets into a favorable 2-1 count. Can the second baseman do something here? Apparently yes as he lines a sharp single up the middle to put the first two runners on.
It doesn’t look like the Yanks are bunting here with Melky Cabrera up. If you had Mientkiewicz hitting in this spot, it would be a good bet. Instead, he pops out harmlessly to short and slams his bat in frustration.
If the Yanks fail to capitalize here, this is a mistake in strategy. You don’t get all four runs back right away. It’s best to chip away. Bunt over and play small ball. Something Torre doesn’t do much of.
Mientkiewicz is quickly in a 1-2 hole. Some mist begins to fall. There was some rain forecast due to the humidity but nothing substantial as the first baseman fouls off another pitch. The count goes full and they got a break finally as Mientkiewicz went around on the check swing. Instead, the normally pitch to contact Byrd loses him to load the bases for Damon as the crowd stands and cheers.
This is a huge moment early here. Byrd gets Damon to pop up to Peralta for the second out.
Jeter comes up with an infield hit for the Yanks’ first run as the bases remain loaded with Abreu coming up. Jeter’s hit was odd because Blake made a nice dive to his right and the ball took a weird hop on him.
The Indians get a lefty Laffey warming up as Abreu takes strike one. He has hit six career grand slams and fared well in these situations hitting over .300.
The Yanks would settle for a base hit to get closer and give themselves momentum.
Instead, Abreu flies out to center as Byrd gets him on a tough pitch. The Cleveland starter has shown a lot of guts thus far in stranding five Yankee runners thru two.
The one good thing is a Yankee finally got a big two out hit with RISP. But they still trail 4-1 as Mussina starts the Cleveland third.
Peralta won’t offer at two close pitches and works a walk to start the inning. The Indians have been very disciplined tonight. Lofton flies to Cabrera.
Mussina gets Gutierrez looking on a nasty pitch down and on the outside corner for the first Indian K. He then follows up by blowing a fastball by Blake to strand a runner.
A-Rod draws more boos by K-ing on three pitches. He took a Byrd pitch right down the heart of the plate. That’s six pitches he’s seen and two K’s. Ugh.
Posada gets ahead 2-0 and then bangs one off the right field wall for a two-bagger. Matsui swings early but Martinez makes a nice play at first unassisted for the second out as Posada advances to third.
Can Cano deliver a big two out hit? Instead, he flies out to deep center stranding another runner. That’s six thru three frames.
Shoppach works Mussina full and then leads off the fourth with a ground rule double to left center. It just appears the Indians won’t chase any bad pitches. They are really putting together great at bats.
Mussina gets ahead of the dangerous Sizemore with a fastball painting the outside. This is a big out here for Moose cause he wants to prevent the runner from moving over. It goes full and Mussina misses outside to put runners on first and second with nobody out.
This could be it. Cabrera sacrifices them over into scoring position for Hafner with Martinez on deck.
Maybe if the Yanks had bunted in a similar spot earlier, they’d be closer. The Yanks have opted to intentionally pass over Hafner for the equally potent Martinez.
Seems like a dangerous strategy here loading the bases. They’re obviously looking for a ground ball to get out of this mess. Martinez is hitting just .100 (2-for-20) for his career against Moose. The count is 1-1. He fouls a pitch off to fall behind. The crowd is begging for a strikeout but a DP would be even better.
Martinez makes them pay by grounding one thru the hole between third and short for a huge two-run single to put Cleveland comfortably in front by five.
This one looks over. Especially when you consider how many runners the Yanks have left on base tonight already.
You have to give the Indians a ton of credit. They’ve come with a great approach.
Mussina then gets Peralta to ground into an inning ending 5-5-3 twin killing. As Caray notes, one batter too late. The damage has been done.
You just wonder if it does end tonight, will The Boss keep his promise and axe Torre? Who could replace the likeable 67 year-old who’s only gotten this team to this point every year since he took over for Buck Showalter winning four world titles in that span and six pennants.
How do you replace a guy like that? Even if we do second guess some of Torre’s decisions, who is out there that can do the job? Don Mattingly who has zero experience and is just there cause of his name? Joe Girardi who couldn’t get along with Florida management? How do you think he’d fare in New York?
Bobby Valentine? It would be hard to believe. The Yanks already have one guy who managed the Mets. Could it work again? Bobby loves Japan.
Bob Brenly who’s working tonight’s game seems to be enjoying doing color on these games along with working at Wrigley for the Cubs? Would his persona want to work here?
There really aren’t many options.
As for the game, the Yanks have Cabrera on first with one out and Damon up. He pops out to right. The Yankees just can’t seem to come up with the big hit against Byrd. They also hit into tough luck as Jeter lines one right to Blake to end the fourth. Five innings left to save their season.
We started cooking a pork chop with special marmalade sauce. Sorry for not updating sooner! But we got hungry.
I’ll tell ya. It’s hard to eat when you know your team probably has four innings left in what’s looking like another disappointing end to an October.
Nice to see A-Rod actually get a hit. But watching Matsui swing from the heels and hit another harmless pop just sums up why this team is looking like another colossal failure.
Their approach against Byrd has stunk. They certainly got enough baserunners on.
Mussina just exited with an out in the sixth to cheers. He did an admirable job giving up just two earned. But unfortunately, it looks like it will be in a bitter loss.
Hey. At least the Buffalo Bills are exposing Tony Romo on MNF. Four interceptions including two for TDs and it’s not even halftime yet. I warned my Cowboy buddy that his team was overrated. Go Bills!
Final line for Moose: 4.2 IP 2 ER 4 H 4 BB 3 K 74 pitches (41 strikes)

You have to ponder if maybe he should’ve gotten the call instead of Wang. Oh well. We’ll never know.
Ron Villone came in and got the final two outs of the sixth. Hafner flies out to left.
Can the Yanks mount a comeback?

Cano goes down and gets a Byrd pitch and belts his second dinger of the series to cut the deficit to four. How much longer will they stay with Byrd? Wedge wisely pulls him and brings in his vaunted pen.
As they show highlights played by even more Bon Jovi, this pork chop and marmalade just rocks. This could be one of our best on the Felix menu.
Did they have to interview Bon Jovi? Overdone much? Craig Sager is just doing his job but he looks a little out of place at a baseball stadium as opposed to basketball arena where the crazy sideline reporter can wear his off the wall jackets.
Wedge isn’t messing around here as Perez gets Melky to bounce out to third.
The Yanks send up Shelly Duncan to pinch hit for Mientkiewicz. The popular PH comes through with a single just out of the reach of Cabrera as cheers go up.
These fans are certainly doing their part in trying to rally their desperate club.
Damon now takes a ball. He then puts one just out of Martinez’ reach and Duncan goes to third. Runners at the corners for the Captain with one out.
Obviously, the situation speaks for itself.

The Indian pen comes through as Perez gets Jeter to hit into another crushing inning ending DP (4-6-3). The past two nights, he’s grounded into three of them. And can any Yankee fan recall the popular shortstop ever hitting into that many in his entire career when it mattered?

Talk about coming up small. It sums up how unclutch this team is in this series.
Apparently, the towel has been waved as Kyle Farn$worth has entered. It’s just as well.
The stunned crowd is silent. They’ve seen plenty of great moments at The House That Ruth Built. But lately, they’ve been witness to awful ones.
The aura appears gone. Will this franchise ever win another playoff round after that epic choke job against the Red Sahhhhxxx?
Maybe The Curse was really reversed and put on the Pinstripes.
I’ve gone on record as saying I’d rather miss the postseason than lose in the first round every year. It’s almost become a tease.
If Cleveland does get the final nine outs to wrap it, they’ll make their skipper look smart because he saved his best two pitchers. They’ll be able to have C.C. Sabathia start in Game One at Fenway and Fausto Carmona for Game Two.
Farnsworth holds the Indians striking out a pair including the final batter on a nasty slider.
Abreu-Rodriguez-Posada due up in the home seventh.
Perez gets Abreu on a nasty pitch down and away. Now Rodriguez comes up and Caray speculates if it’s his final at bat in a Yankee uniform.
It’s hard to just blame him for this. Not when Jeter has failed big time and Posada and Abreu haven’t driven in a run either. Matsui hasn’t exactly torn the cover off the ball either.
But can any Yankee fan actually support bringing the best player in the game back at a whopping $32 million-per-year? Even if he is the greatest player in the game, they haven’t won anything with him. The price will be astronomical due to the world’s most evil agent Scott Boras. Can’t he just go away?
His client’s asking price just increased because A-Rod finally broke his RBI playoff drought with a long solo blast to death valley to slice it to three.
It’s the closest they’ve been since the first. You almost get the impression that was his goodbye swing to the fans. “Hell-o Anaheim.”
Posada grounded out for the second out. Seven outs left.
Matsui puts together a good AB showing discipline by not going out of the zone to draw a two out walk bringing Cano to the plate.
This is probably Perez’ last batter.
Caray pointed out that the Rodriguez home run was the first earned run the Cleveland pen has allowed in 10+ innings.
Cano gets the count to 2-0.
If he does find a way on, Betancourt is warming for Duncan. But Brenly points out that Torre would counter with Jason Giambi. Moot point as Cano bounces out to first.
Six outs remaining.
You look at the boxscore and see the three runs on 11 hits while Cleveland has six on one fewer hit. It speaks volumes about this series.
Jose Veras comes on to pitch the eighth for the Yanks.
Random thought. Why does Tony Gwynn sound like he should be in a Western? Just saying.
Veras makes short work of Blake on three pitches. Shoppach narrowly misses a solo homer off the left center fence for a stand up double.
It looks like Torre is going to bring in Mariano Rivera for the final stand.
As he comes out, the knowledgable Yankee crowd salutes the popular manager with “Joe Torre, Joe Torre, Joe Torre,” chants.
They realize it could be the final time they see him in Pinstripes.
He has Veras intentionally walk Sizemore, then comes out to more salutes from the crowd and brings in the Sandman.
Mo gets Cabrera to bounce into a 4-6 force for the second out. He then has Hafner hit a tough chopper which a hustling Jeter dug out and threw accurately and in time to get the final out.
And yet again our favorite plate ump apparently missed another catcher’s interference as the Indians came out to argue and indeed, the replay indicated that Hafner’s bat barely made contact with Posada’s glove.
But Culbreth missed it. Great umpiring crew. They really have been befuddled. It’s how not to umpire. My Dad is appalled. He officiates and well I might add.
The Indians bring in Betancourt who has walked just nine in almost 80 innings this season while K-ing 80. What an amazing ratio.
Cabrera is down in the count 0-2. Melky hits it hard but right at Peralta who calmly fields it and throws just in time to get him.
Five outs to go.
Giambi now will pinch hit for Duncan. Man. What a diminished role he has now. I bet this isn’t what he signed up for or what the Yanks spent all those big bucks after 2001 for. Would anyone have believed he’d be without a ring broken down with a wasted contract?Fittingly, he whiffs.
Four outs left. Damon K’s to end the inning.
Three outs to go. And you could just see Mike Lupica with his A-Rod voodoo doll foaming at the mouth along with all the cruddy Mets fans whose team bit the dust in an epic collapse before October. Their time apparently didn’t come. But Lupica still foolishly believed that joke of a team with no chemistry could do something had they made it here. What is he smoking? We’d like some. I do have a Bob Marley t-shirt on. But come on.
It looks like a 73-39 finish and a 6-0 regular season record against this same team will go to waste unless a furious rally happens.
Brenly makes a very solid point that if Torre is indeed gone if his team falls short, they could not only lose the skipper but some players as well. Posada and Rivera have built close relationships with him and A-Rod has also taken to the manager after finishing last Fall batting eighth at Detroit.
This could be the final time Yankee fans see Rivera and Posada in a Yankee uniform. If you live and die with this team, take it in.
The first two Indians get broken bat seeing eye singles probably reminding Brenly of November 2001 in Arizona.
It’s tough to watch this but that’s baseball. Mo gets Lofton to hit into a 6-4 fielder’s choice as the crowd gasps.
The good news for the Yanks is that their staff will be much younger next year. Naysayers will no longer be able to point to the age of the arms for not coming through at this time of year. With Joba Chamberlain, Ian Kennedy and Phil Hughes all future staples in the rotation along with Wang, the Bombers should have one of the deepest and youngest staffs in the majors.
The bigger question is who else will be in that dugout?
Rivera K’s Gutierrez swinging for the second Indian out with runners at the corners.
Another “Let’s Go Yankee” chant comes up from the crowd and then Damon flat out robs Blake of a certain bases clearing double which would’ve dashed any minor Bomber hope of a last inning comeback.
That kind of D from the leadoff hitter who shifted from center to left is why he should still be on this team as their left fielder next Spring. Matsui is a DH.
Now the middle of the order comes up against Joe Borowski who worked a scoreless frame last night pitching around a couple of walks.
Back in April, the same team cameback and scored six in a miraculous walkoff win with a grand slam from A-Rod.
Different time now. Here we go.
Jeter starts it off. His two hits may as well be meaningless because of the DP he grounded into to end the sixth. And the shortstop pops out to second and even he hears boos. It’s hard to blame them though. He’s been equally as responsible as any big hitter for this.
Now Abreu. He hammers a Borowski two strike pitch into the right field upper deck to slice the deficit to two. It’s the third solo shot of the night for the Yanks. And all you could think of is where was that when they had all those runners on base?
Now Rodriguez in what could just be his final at bat in Pinstripes. He swings through an outside Borowski offering to fall behind 0-2. Please A-Rod. Don’t strike out. The count goes to 1-2. He nearly is struck out but the Borowski pitch just misses the outside corner to even it up. He goes the other way and pops out to right for the second out. Chased a high fastball which would’ve been ball three.
The camera zooms in on a helpless Torre and then Rodriguez looks on quiet as Posada steps into the box in what might be his last AB as a Yankee as well.
And one of the most valuable Yankees in the last decade. The catcher misses another solo homer by 20 feet. It’s now 0-2. Instead, he strikes out swinging and that’s it.
The Indians storm onto the field to greet Borowski as a shocked crowd just sits in silence.
The camera shows Rodriguez sitting there watching. Officially a free agent. And it’s hard to call such a special player a loser in Yankee Pinstripes. But ever since that cruel series against Boston, it’s been nothing but sad faces this time of year for him, teammates and management.
What ashame. It looks like an era is over. And who knows what this team will look like next year. One thing is certain. There will be changes. You just wonder if they’ll be the right ones for a proud franchise which now can’t get it done in October.
Congrats to the Indians. They deserved this series badly. They wanted it and delivered with clutch hits and better pitching.
You have to give them credit. Most didn’t think they could wrap this ALDS on that field. But it’s officially become the field of heartbreak and heartache.
2003- Florida
2004- Boston
2007-Cleveland
It’s a series like this and those recent failures which makes us glad we cover the minor league A ball team out here in Staten Island. A bunch of hungry kids who want to win and blend well.
The encouraging news for Yankee fans is that there’s a lot of talent coming through the system. I really didn’t believe this team could get to the World Series as currently constituted. They didn’t have enough pitching and needed the hitters to come through. Instead, that never happened and they were victimized by a younger team whose approach was what these Bombers used to have in them.
And so it will be Indians-Sahhhxx in the ALCS. We’ll have our prediction along with Rockies-Diamondbacks tomorrow.